| Bills | Pos | Name | HT | WT | School | Grade | Starter |
| R-1 | CB | Stephon Gilmore | 6’0” | 190lbs | S. Carolina | B+ | Yes |
| R-2 | OL | Cordy Glenn | 6’5” | 345lbs | Georgia | A+ | Yes |
| R-3 | Wr | T.J. Graham | 5’11” | 188lbs | N.C. State | C- | Some PT |
| R-4a | OLB | Nigel Bradham | 6’2” | 241lbs | Florida State | C+ | Some PT |
| R-4b | CB | Ron Brooks | 5’10” | 190lbs | LSU | C+ | Some PT |
| R-5a | OT | Zebrie Sanders | 6’5” | 320lbs | Florida State | A+ | Yes |
| R-5b | LB | Tank Carder | 6’2” | 236lbs | TCU | B+ | Some PT |
| R-6 | OL | Mark Asper | 6’6” | 319lbs | Oregon | A- | No |
| R-7 | K | John Potter | W. Michigan | C | Maybe | ||
| Overall Grade | B+ | ||||||
| Patriots | |||||||
| R-1a | DE | Chandler Jones | 6’5” | 247lbs | Syracuse | B+ | Yes |
| R-1b | LB | Dont’a Hightower | 6’2” | 265lbs | Alabama | A- | Yes |
| R-2 | S | Tavon Wilson | 6’0” | 205lbs | Illinois | C- | No |
| R-3 | DE | Jake Bequette | 6”5” | 274lbs | Arkansas | B+ | Some PT |
| R-6 | DB | Nate Ebner | 6’0” | 200lbs | Ohio State | D+ | No |
| R-7a | CB | Alfonzo Dennard | 5’10” | 204lbs | Nebraska | A+ | Maybe |
| R-7b | Wr | Jeremy Ebert | 5’11” | 200lbs | Northwestern | D- | No |
| Overall Grade | B | ||||||
| Dolphins | |||||||
| R-1 | QB | Ryan Tannehill | 6’4” | 221lbs | Texas A&M | C- | Yes |
| R-2 | OT | Jon Martin | 6’5” | 312lbs | Stanford | A+ | Yes |
| R-3a | OLB | Olivier Vernon | 6’2” | 262lbs | Miami | C+ | Maybe |
| R-3b | Te | Michael Egnew | 6’5” | 252lbs | Missouri | B+ | Maybe |
| R-4 | RB | Lamar Miller | 5’11” | 212lbs | Miami | A- | Some PT |
| R-5 | OLB | Josh Kaddu | 6’3” | 240lbs | Oregon | B | Some PT |
| R-6 | Wr | B.J. Cunningham | 6’1” | 211lbs | Mich State | C+ | Some PT |
| R-7a | DT | Kheeston Randall | 6’4” | 293lbs | Texas | A- | Some PT |
| R-7b | Wr | Rishard Mathews | 6’0” | 212lbs | Nevada | D+ | No |
| Overall Grade | B | ||||||
| Jets | |||||||
| R-1 | DE | Quinton Coples | 6’6” | 284lbs | N. Carolina | A- | Yes |
| R-2 | Wr | Stephen Hill | 6’4” | 215lbs | G-Tech | B+ | Yes |
| R-3 | OLB | Demario Davis | 6’2” | 235lbs | Arknasas St | D+ | No |
| R-6a | S | Josh Bush | 5’11” | 208lbs | Wake | D- | No |
| R-6b | RB | Terrance Ganaway | 6’0” | 239lbs | Baylor | A- | Some PT |
| R-6c | OG | Robert T. Griffin | 6’6” | 335lbs | Baylor | C- | No |
| R-7 | S | Antonio Allen | 6’1” | 210lbs | S. Carolina | A | Maybe |
| Overall Grade | C+ |
